预报模式升级对CMA全球集合预报系统冬季预报的影响研究

Impacts of the forecast model upgrade on wintertime forecast by the CMA global ensemble prediction system

  • 摘要: 传统的集合预报以确定性模式为基础,其性能直接受确定性模式预报质量的影响。中国气象局全球预报系统(CMA-GFS)于2023年实现V3.3向V4.0的业务升级,其水平分辨率与预报性能得到显著提升,这为依托该模式的CMA全球集合预报系统(CMA-GEPS)改进提供关键基础。为厘清预报模式升级对CMA-GEPS冬季预报的影响,以业务上CMA-GEPS V1.3为基准,利用CMA-GFS V3.3和V4.0构建了仅预报模式不同的两个集合预报试验系统,针对2024年冬季开展了两组31 d的集合预报对比试验,并从扰动特征、统计评分及典型个例三方面展开分析。结果显示,预报模式由CMA-GFS V3.3升级为V4.0后,CMA-GEPS集合扰动对预报误差的捕捉能力略微增强、扰动增长更快;多数检验要素集合离散度(SPD)显著增大,仅热带地区高层温度集合平均均方根误差(RMSE)变差,其余要素RMSE变化不大或有所改善,因而,大部分情况下,SPD与集合平均RMSE差距缩小,集合可靠性提升;除热带地区高层温度外,连续分级概率预报评分与预报失误率以减小为主,概率预报技巧提高;中国地区小雨预报效果变化不大,中雨及大雨预报有一定程度改善。综上,预报模式升级整体提升了CMA-GEPS冬季预报性能,针对11月下旬一次东北地区典型降温天气过程的分析进一步验证了这一结论。但新模式引入的SPD增量加剧了CMA-GEPS位势高度在预报前期的过发散问题,所以,即使集合预报初值扰动技术、模式扰动方案、水平分辨率和集合成员数保持不变,预报模式更新后仍有必要开展扰动参数调优工作,从而实现CMA集合预报水平的全方位提升。未来仍需进一步探讨预报模式升级对其他季节集合预报性能的影响。

     

    Abstract: Traditional ensemble forecasts are based on deterministic models, and their performance is directly affected by the forecast quality of the deterministic models they rely on. The China Meteorological Administration Global Forecast System (CMA-GFS) was upgraded from V3.3 to V4.0 in 2023, resulting in significant improvements in both its horizontal resolution and forecast performance. This upgrade also provides a crucial foundation for optimizing the CMA Global Ensemble Prediction System (CMA-GEPS) with the CMA-GFS as the forecast model. To investigate the impact of the forecast model update on CMA-GEPS forecasts in wintertime, the operational CMA-GEPS V1.3 is taken as the baseline in this paper, and two ensemble forecast experimental systems are constructed using CMA-GFS V3.3 and V4.0, respectively, with the only difference lying in the forecast model. Two groups of 31 d ensemble forecast comparative experiments for the winter season of 2024 are carried out, and analyses are implemented from three perspectives, i.e., perturbation characteristics, statistical scores, and a representative case study. Results show that after the forecast model is updated from CMA-GFS V3.3 to V4.0, the ability of ensemble perturbations from CMA-GEPS to capture the forecast errors is slightly improved, and the perturbations grow faster. Moreover, the ensemble spread (SPD) of most elements verified increase significantly. Except that the ensemble mean Root-Mean-Square Errors (RMSE) of upper-level temperature in the tropical region deteriorate, the RMSEs of other variables remain nearly unchanged or improved. Overall, the gap between SPD and the ensemble mean RMSE becomes narrow, suggesting an enhanced ensemble reliability. Apart from the upper-level temperature in the tropical region, both the Continuous Ranked Probability Score (CRPS) and Outlier primarily decline, indicating improved probabilistic forecast skills. Over China, the forecast skill of light rain is nearly unchanged, and forecasts of moderate rain and heavy rain are improved to some extent. In summary, the forecast model upgrade generally improves the wintertime forecast performance of CMA-GEPS, which is further confirmed through the analysis of a representative cooling weather process in the northeastern region of China in late November. However, the increased SPD introduced by the new forecast model exacerbates the over-dispersive problem of the geopotential height forecast from CMA-GEPS during the early forecast period. Therefore, even if the initial perturbation technology, model perturbation strategy, horizontal resolution, and ensemble size of the ensemble prediction system are kept unchanged, it is still necessary to optimize the perturbation parameters after updating the forecast model to achieve a comprehensive improvement of the CMA ensemble forecast skill. In the future, impacts of the forecast model upgrade on CMA-GEPS in other seasons will be further explored.

     

/

返回文章
返回